Our History

Thankful for the past, rejoicing in the present, preparing for the future.

~Psalm 145:4~

1917 – 1927: Humble Beginnings 

The story of the Church of God in Toledo began in September 1917, when three faithful women—Sisters Sallie Foster, A. V. Burns, and Janis Barber—began holding cottage meetings and Bible studies. Their vision and determination laid the foundation for what would become a century-long ministry. By May 1918, this “Little Congregation” found its first gathering place at 103 Vinal Street, the home of Rev. and Mrs. William Carter. That same year marked the birth of the first African American congregation of the Church of God in Toledo. 

In 1919, the first Sunday School was organized, with Brother William Carter serving as the church’s first pastor. The young congregation moved several times—first to Collingwood and Avondale, then to Erie and Tecumseh—before establishing a permanent home in 1923 with the construction of a brick church at 385 Vance Street. 

The 1920s were a season of growth and new beginnings. In 1924, the first choir was organized under Brother Joe Faulcon, with Brother Frank Lindsey accompanying on piano. Leadership shifted as Rev. Carter resigned, Rev. Lindsey served as interim pastor, and Sister Lucinda Vines became the church’s first woman pastor. By 1927, Rev. Sharp briefly stepped in to serve the congregation. 

1928 – 1937: A Spiritual Father’s Leadership 

In November 1928, Rev. Hammond Jeter was installed as pastor. Remembered as a “Spiritual Father,” Rev. Jeter helped the congregation grow in faith and structure. In 1932, the first Deaconess Board was formed, followed by the election of Sister Wynona as Sunday School Superintendent in 1934. That same year, the first Missionary Society began its work. In May 1935, history was made when Sister Matie Hill became the church’s first ordained Elder. On April 19, 1936, the congregation relocated to a new property at 615 Collingwood, which became its spiritual home. 

1938 – 1947: Strength Through Transition 

The church reached a milestone on September 26, 1943, when it celebrated the burning of the mortgage at 615 Collingwood under the leadership of Brother Joseph Crosswhite. But soon after, in 1944, Rev. Jeter passed away, leaving a legacy of faith. Leadership was taken up by Rev. C. M. Washington, who guided the church through a period of growth. One of his lasting contributions was the organization of the Board of Christian Education in 1946, providing structure for the teaching ministry of the church. 

1948 – 1957: Seasons of Change 

The late 1940s and 1950s were marked by frequent pastoral transitions. Rev. Washington resigned in October 1948, and within a short period, Rev. Nathaniel Owens, Rev. Clifton Morgan, and Rev. Robert Moody each served the congregation. Rev. Moody, installed in 1950, pastored faithfully for two and a half years. Rev. Smith Davis briefly pastored in 1953, after which Rev. Owens returned and shared the pulpit with Rev. John Early. 

During this era, Rev. John Early, along with Rev. Charles Myers and Rev. Lila Myers, became key leaders in sustaining the ministry. Finally, in October 1955, Rev. Leonard Roache was installed as pastor. His steady leadership for over five years brought renewed stability to the church. 

1958 – 1987: Growth and Community Impact 

The next three decades were seasons of steady growth. The church thrived through vibrant worship, dynamic choirs, and expanding ministries for men, women, youth, and children. Fellowship and discipleship deepened, while outreach programs strengthened the church’s presence in the Toledo community. These years cemented the church’s role as a spiritual home for generations of families, many of whom continued to rise into leadership. 

1988 – 2007: A Thriving Center of Ministry 

By the late 1980s and 1990s, the church had matured into a thriving center of worship and ministry. Members celebrated milestones together, launched new outreach opportunities, and nurtured spiritual growth across all ages. Entering the 2000s, the church embraced both tradition and innovation, weaving together dynamic worship services with creative ministry efforts that engaged the broader community. 

2008 – 2017: Preparing for the Centennial 

As the church moved toward its centennial anniversary, it reflected deeply on its legacy. Ministries flourished, new leaders were trained, and the congregation celebrated the faith of earlier generations while pressing forward in vision. In 2017, the Church of God in Toledo celebrated 100 years of ministry—honoring its humble beginnings in a small home on Vinal Street and rejoicing in the legacy of faith, perseverance, and community that had carried it through a century. 

2018 – 2025: A New Era of Vision 

A fresh chapter opened in 2018 with the appointment of Pastor Carol W. Ligons as Assistant Pastor, strengthening the pastoral team. On September 17, 2022, the congregation celebrated the Installation Service of Pastor Eric V. Butler and First Lady Twila Butler, ushering in a new era of vision and leadership. In May 2023, the church honored Bishop Robert A. and Dr. Maggie L. Culp with a retirement celebration, giving thanks for their years of faithful service. 

Now, in 2025, the Church of God in Toledo stands as a testimony of God’s faithfulness. More than a century after three women first gathered in prayer and teaching, the church remains a beacon of light—rooted in its past, vibrant in the present, and hopeful for the future. Generation after generation, it continues to carry forward the mission: to reach souls for Christ and to be a living witness of God’s enduring love.